FLINK and STAV chronology witnesses¶
The replay pairs two hash-bound private Rootsi workbooks with the retained Neotoma/EPD source download. The report preserves source identities, depth joins, age comparisons, and count-cell status without copying the private workbook cells. The Rootsi overlap ledger remains a candidate metadata relation; this narrower check adds source-row evidence. The earlier workbook audit records the unaltered age cells and their reversals.
| Sequence | Source relation | Chronology finding |
|---|---|---|
| FLINK | All 109 workbook depth numbers match Neotoma dataset 54024 after multiplying by 100; the workbook header does not state a depth unit. All 270 explicit pollen-NISP pairs for the three labeled Betula, Pinus and Populus columns agree; 57 workbook zeros have no matching archive row. | The arithmetic 1950 − Neotoma calibrated BP agrees with 108 of 109 workbook cal AD/BC labels within 0.05 year. At workbook sheet row 56, Neotoma depth 275 cm, the workbook says +3910.8433, while Neotoma sample 553036 says 5860.8 BP, implying −3910.8 under that arithmetic. The sole mismatch is a source discrepancy; the workbook was not changed. |
| STAV | All 77 workbook depth numbers match those of Neotoma dataset 54003 directly. Of 940 exact-name, explicit pollen-NISP cell pairs, all 940 counts agree. | The workbook has no age column. Neotoma chronology 38423 supplies 77 point ages spanning 70–10585 calibrated BP, with no per-sample older or younger bounds. This is a candidate age vector for the same depth axis, not an authenticated LandClim input chronology. |
STAV's remaining 5,374 workbook count cells have no single exact-name Neotoma pollen NISP row: 4,520 workbook zeros and 854 positives. Some workbook columns describe other elements or use different names, so those cells cannot be interpreted as archive zeros or count disagreements. This check does not close the count denominator or taxon mapping.
The Neotoma record identifies FLINK chronology 38438 as OxCal v3.10/IntCal04 and STAV chronology 38423 as Bacon. These are shared EPD source-lineage witnesses, not independent validations of the authors' historical LandClim inputs or age uncertainty. The publisher metadata's FLINK bounds of −50 to 12011 BP agree with the Neotoma age extrema after rounding, while the single workbook sign discrepancy explains the workbook-only impossible −1961 BP extremum. An authoritative corrected FLINK workbook value still requires a source-holder record. STAV's historical age-model version and row membership also remain unconfirmed. Workbook analytical-use rights, time-specific basin geometry, and complete target denominators are unresolved. Neither sequence is admitted to LRA or dated-event claims by this comparison.
The underlying source archive records are FLINK and STAV. The report binds the exact repository Neotoma download SHA-256 and each private workbook SHA-256.
Reproduce from the repository root:
PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 .venv/bin/python \
docs/report/source-relations/landclim/neotoma-chronology-witness/replay.py \
--source-root ../bijux-pollenomics-data/landclim/rootsi-workbooks \
--output artifacts/jobs/rootsi-neotoma-chronology-witness/report.json
cmp artifacts/jobs/rootsi-neotoma-chronology-witness/report.json \
docs/report/source-relations/landclim/neotoma-chronology-witness/report.json