RAĶ
RAÄ is intended to supply dense, Sweden-specific archaeology context from Riksantikvarieämbetet's published Fornsök/Open Data surfaces. The repository retains capture metadata and derived density files for audit, but does not currently admit them as governed archaeology evidence. Under decision D2-033, the exact byte-identical v0.1.8 density pair is visible by default as degraded historical context. RAÄ authority remains refused until the raw inventory, raw summary, normalized counts, and qualified scientific review reconcile.
Checked-In Evidence¶
| Surface | Current state | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| source inventory denominator | unavailable | no admitted raw inventory and raw summary reconcile the retained metadata |
| classified-record denominators | unavailable | retained summary values are not governed evidence while authority is refused |
| density cells | 106 retained cells, default-visible as degraded context | the exact historical surface is display-only, not admitted RAÄ evidence |
| temporal evidence | not applicable | the refused density surface cannot contribute dated evidence or same-period comparison |
Missing governed denominators are not scientific zeros. The 106 retained cell
values sum to 339,412, while retained metadata reports 318,265
Fornlämning WFS hits. The historical producer requested the national hit
count once and each one-degree cell's hit count in a separate BBOX query. It
did not archive one source inventory and assign each record to one cell. The
arithmetic difference of 21,147 therefore compares unbound query
denominators; it is not a measured count of duplicate or missing records.
Cell-boundary overlap, source changes between requests, and spatial reach are
possible contributors, but the retained files have no record IDs, per-query
responses, or capture times to assign any share of the difference. The cell
values remain display-only and cannot support an analytical RAÄ count.
flowchart LR
Source["Fornsök and RAÄ Open Data"] --> Capture["partial retained capture"]
Capture --> Refusal["authority refused"]
Refusal --> Missing["inventory, summary, and review required"]
Missing --> Future["future governed density assessment"]
Read A Density Cell¶
A retained cell currently shows only the numeric value preserved in the exact historical one-degree surface. It cannot be called a governed RAÄ record count. After authority admission and regeneration, a cell could answer the bounded question of how many governed records in a selected class fall within the aggregation area. In the current refused state it establishes none of the following:
- a complete inventory of past activity;
- uniform survey or registration effort;
- chronology shared by records inside the cell;
- association with a nearby pollen, lake, fieldwork, or aDNA feature; or
- site-level distance from a feature to every contributing record.
Cell size is part of the result. A one-degree aggregation supports broad national or regional context, not precise local-distance reasoning. Rendering the cell with a smooth color ramp does not increase spatial resolution.
Aggregation Contract¶
| Layer | Observation unit | Defensible denominator | Spatial meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| source summary | WFS feature hit in the historical query | unavailable while authority is refused | one national query, without an archived disjoint record inventory |
| classified summary | record in a declared RAÄ class | the selected classification population | classification count, not event count |
| density layer | one-degree cell | 106 historical cells; count population unresolved | degraded display of the retained value only |
| map rendering | colored cell polygon | 106 display members, zero scientifically admitted members | visual orientation with authority and count warnings |
The transformation changes the observation unit. A statement about a density cell must cite the cell and classification contract; a statement about an individual RAÄ record requires the source record, which the public density surface does not expose.
Retain The Aggregation Receipt¶
A density comparison is reusable only when the aggregation choices travel with the cell value:
| Receipt field | Required meaning |
|---|---|
| source population | governed RAÄ capture and source classification included |
| membership predicate | rule assigning source records to cells |
| grid definition | cell geometry, resolution, coordinate reference system, and boundary convention |
| numerator | count of admitted registry records in the named cell |
| denominator | selected source population or comparison-cell population used by the claim |
| missing and duplicate posture | treatment of unusable geometry, repeated identities, and multi-part records |
| product identity | publication version and stable cell identifier |
flowchart LR
Records["selected RAÄ records"] --> Predicate["declared cell-membership rule"]
Grid["versioned one-degree grid"] --> Predicate
Predicate --> Cell["stable density-cell member"]
Cell --> Receipt["count, denominator, and aggregation receipt"]
Receipt --> Context["qualified archaeology-density context"]
Two cells are comparable only under the same source population, classification, grid, and membership rule. Equal color classes from different contracts are visually similar, not necessarily quantitatively comparable.
Audit An Archaeology-Density Claim¶
- Read the visible authority posture first. The current repository state is degraded/refused and cannot support an archaeology-density claim even though the exact historical layer is displayed.
- Identify the Sweden product, RAÄ layer, cell, historical-pair hashes and unbound 339,412-cell-sum versus 318,265-national-query comparison. After admission, identify the current capture and classification being read and confirm that its counts share one capture.
- Treat the cell value as an aggregate count, not a site-level distance or a chronology statement.
- State the one-degree spatial support and Sweden-only reach.
- When comparing with SEAD, retain both observation units and do not add their counts into one archaeology population.
- For a stronger local or temporal claim, return to the appropriate source records rather than interpolating detail from the color scale.
Relationship To SEAD¶
| Dimension | RAÄ | SEAD |
|---|---|---|
| reach | Sweden-specific | broader environmental-archaeology context |
| current public geometry | 106 degraded historical density cells | normalized site points |
| temporal posture | refused; no admitted time dimension | mixed site envelopes: numeric where linked chronology supports them, otherwise label-only or unresolved |
| strongest use | retained provenance pending authority admission | wider site-centered archaeology context |
| invalid shortcut | generalize Swedish density to the Nordic region | infer same-period evidence from undated proximity |
The families are complementary and must not be merged into one archaeology denominator. Their observation units, geographic reach, spatial resolution, and capture depth differ.
Governing Surfaces¶
data/raa/raw/arkreg_v1_0_wfs_capabilities.xmlpreserves service capability context;data/raa/raw/publicerade_lamningar_centrumpunkt_schema.xmlpreserves the captured feature schema;data/raa/raw/fornsok_domains.jsonpreserves governed domain values;data/raa/normalized/sweden_archaeology_layer.jsongoverns counts, cell size, classification, and source identity; anddata/raa/normalized/sweden_archaeology_density.geojsongoverns the visible density geometry.
Public maps may display only the exact D2-033 historical pair while authority remains refused. The layer must remain visibly degraded, display-only, chronology-absent and propagation-ineligible; any substituted pair is excluded. Continue to RAÄ exports for the publication role and source comparison before combining RAÄ with another family.
National GeoPackage Source Candidate¶
The private source store holds the exact 2026-09-12 national GeoPackage named in
data/raa/raw/national_geopackage_source.json (2,291,224,576 bytes; recorded
SHA-256 96bbe197a84c70b64f047873ded15ce5df568198dc0794870a782decb82fed0b).
Its RAÄ download directory
lists lämningar_sverige.gpkg. The RAÄ technical description, version
1.1 identifies that exact
lamningar_v1 production endpoint, the national GeoPackage delivery, SWEREF
99 TM, and the lämningar_sverige_point, line, polygon, and positional
uncertainty layers. The directory is regenerated: its current listing is not
evidence that today's bytes equal the retained September capture.
The linked RAÄ product description, version 3.0 governs Kulturhistoriska lämningar, including its GeoPackage download. It states that the dataset is outside copyright and free to use (Public Domain), with no access restriction. RAÄ asks users to name the source and date when redistributing information because the register changes continuously. This resolves the dataset-level analytical reuse and redistribution question for the captured national download; it does not grant rights to separately linked images or documents, establish a scientific population, or admit the historical density layer.
The captured GeoPackage's read-only container metadata names lamning.uuid,
point.lamning_uuid, and the national point view's uuid; the RAÄ technical
description defines these as the remains identity. The retained legacy WFS
schema instead exposes lamning_id, lamningsnummer, and a centrumpunkt.
Both sources expose a remains number, but their field names alone do not prove
row identity, population equivalence, or that the legacy center point matches a
native point geometry. A record-level crosswalk, source date and class comparison,
and geometry review are still required before replacing the point source or
regenerating density. No event dates or historical associations follow from this
container-level comparison.
The RAÄ source package provides a private read-only ownership audit for the inspected national GeoPackage profile. Callers pin complete local source bytes, and saved inspection reconstructs every source row before returning lineage. Native records, included remains, direct/nested properties and separate point/line/polygon/positional-uncertainty rows retain their original identities and scalar values. Container-header accounting does not validate geometry or derive representative coordinates. This capability does not adopt a canonical source release or change historical density authority, chronology, country assignments, or scientific-review posture. Native GeoPackages and large row inventories remain in caller-selected local data directories. Git retains the audit implementation and compact contracts; a local raw capture does not by itself change public source admission.
Legacy point/density validation requires explicit reconciled populations and a native identifier for every feature. It refuses missing, boolean or fractional counts, conflicting population aliases, omitted/malformed features, duplicate JSON keys and nonfinite values. Zero remains a valid declared count. Invalid density cells make the total unavailable instead of contributing a fabricated zero. These checks preserve the historical population discrepancy and source review requirements; they do not validate geometry or create source approval.