Skip to content

Sweden Lake Priorities

The current governed Sweden lake ranking has zero admitted candidates. Its report records governing_svar_registry_missing: the normalized SMHI SVAR registry needed to verify lake identity and derive the candidate population is absent from the governed source tree. The fieldwork preparation screen is empty for the same reason. No current lake rank, fieldwork order, score, or shortlist is available.

A separate derived review subset at data/svar/review/sweden_lake_candidate_registry.geojson contains 99 map features. It does not replace the full normalized registry or its source authority. The retained candidate review refers to 40,523 source lakes, whereas a separately recovered normalized export contains 40,565. That population mismatch and the missing source capture require reconciliation and qualified review before either source can support a new ranking. The recovery record preserves the recovered export's identity and limits.

What the ranking would measure

The ranking design compares evidence linked to an identified official lake: nearby human ancient DNA, direct and nearby pollen, archaeology, animal context, evidence diversity, and an area-based lake screen. The declared weight profile and 10, 20, 30, 40, and 50 km distance bands are documented in the report. These are a model definition, not an evaluated score for any current lake.

Evidence richness is distinct from coring suitability. Even a supported high rank would not establish bathymetry, intact sediment, lake access, permits, landowner consent, conservation compatibility, field safety, or a sampling protocol. The Lyngsjön visit is a separate dated observation and does not supply those missing measurements for the ranking.

Admission and decision path

flowchart LR
    Source["verified full lake registry"] --> Identity["reviewed lake identity"]
    Identity --> Context["source-linked context"]
    Context --> Ranking["versioned ranking and sensitivity"]
    Ranking --> Desk["bathymetry, sediment, access and permits"]
    Desk --> Decision["dated expert advance, defer or reject decision"]
    Decision --> Field["site-specific field assessment"]

Before restoring the ranking, the full registry and its candidate subset need matching source counts, content identities, official lake identifiers, polygon geometry, names and representative points. Temporal claims need source-owned chronology. Source classes with unavailable authority remain context or are excluded under the governed method; an absent value cannot be scored as an observed zero.

A desk decision dossier for each reviewed lake must preserve the ranked result and its version separately from the later decision. It needs source identity, contributing evidence, basin morphology, bathymetry, sediment conditions, shoreline and boat access, ownership and permissions, conservation limits, hazards, logistics, dated field observations with contributor and media lineage, and an expert reason for advancing, deferring or rejecting. Missing essential field evidence blocks advancement. A map visit or ranking row cannot be relabeled as sampling ready.

The current zero-candidate report therefore supports a defer posture for new ranking-based field decisions. It is not an expert rejection of a particular lake. Existing named southern Sweden sites and the Lyngsjön visit remain separate source and fieldwork records, without a current rank inferred from them.

Current governed outputs