Skip to content

Galician cattle primary-paper review

The source review identifies the primary PLOS One article for BioProject PRJNA705960. The paper explicitly names that BioProject. Its dating supplement and sequencing supplement are retained with the article under data/adna/review/galician_cattle/. The 2022 correction corrects the third author's name. Eleven ENA BioSample XML records are retained under data/adna/review/galician_cattle/biosamples/. The report records byte counts, SHA-256 digests, original URLs, and the governed ENA archive-metadata digest.

Source population Count Species evidence
Dating supplement specimen rows 18 15 Bos taurus, 3 Bos primigenius
Sequencing supplement paper labels 11 8 Bt_ labels, 3 Bp_ labels
ENA BioSample accessions for the BioProject 11 8 Bos taurus, 3 Bos primigenius source taxon rows

These are three distinct identity units. Each source-owned ENA BioSample alias matches exactly one label in the paper dating supplement after punctuation normalization; the report retains all eleven accession, alias, paper-row, specimen-code, and species pairs. Every pair agrees on source species. This establishes the sample identity crosswalk without resolving sample locality or chronology or admitting an atlas point.

The current project catalog is owned by Bos taurus and its primary-paper field remains unpinned. Three of its eleven archive samples are source-owned Bos primigenius. Promoting the paper link without correcting mixed-species ownership would hide a real source conflict. This review records the paper as an identified source candidate while retaining the sample-owned 8/3 taxonomy. Locality, chronology, and point admission remain unresolved. The Galician project supplies no Nordic sample by itself.

Reproduce

From the repository root, after make root-check-env, run:

PYTHONPATH=packages/bijux-pollenomics-dev/src:packages/bijux-pollenomics/src \
PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 artifacts/root/check-venv/bin/python -m \
  bijux_pollenomics_dev.source_completion.galician_cattle_review \
  --repository . \
  --output artifacts/release-verification/galician-cattle-paper-reproduction.json

The producer checks the article DOI and BioProject, correction scope, both supplement row populations, eleven unique archive accessions, and the eleven source-owned BioSample aliases. It refuses a missing or colliding paper alias, paper/archive taxonomy disagreement, or a changed source identity. Five focused regressions cover the identity and refusal rules.