{ "schema_version": "atlas-evidence-surface.v2", "countries": [ "Sweden", "Norway", "Finland", "Denmark" ], "layers": [ { "layer_key": "homo_sapiens_direct", "label": "Homo sapiens direct evidence", "species_scope": [ "Homo sapiens" ], "layer_role": "mapped_direct", "mapped": true, "feature_count": 447, "evidence_posture": "mapped_locality_direct_evidence", "provenance_posture": "aadr_metadata_only", "popup_contract": [ "Species", "Evidence role", "Source family", "Source release", "Record modality", "Review strength", "Provenance quality", "Coordinate confidence", "Dating basis" ], "rationale": [ "This is the mapped Homo sapiens direct ancient-DNA layer." ] }, { "layer_key": "animal_domesticated_direct", "label": "Domesticated-core animal direct evidence", "species_scope": [ "Bos taurus", "Camelus dromedarius", "Canis lupus familiaris", "Capra hircus", "Equus caballus", "Felis catus", "Ovis aries", "Sus scrofa domesticus" ], "layer_role": "mapped_direct", "mapped": true, "feature_count": 2, "evidence_posture": "mapped_species_owned_locality_evidence", "provenance_posture": "tracked_species_locality_summaries", "popup_contract": [ "Species", "Support class", "Project accession", "Paper title", "Publication year", "Chronology", "Coordinate confidence", "Nordic relevance", "Interpretation", "Warning" ], "rationale": [ "Domesticated-core animal species now ship mapped locality leads in the atlas bundle." ] }, { "layer_key": "animal_comparator_direct", "label": "Comparator animal direct evidence", "species_scope": [ "Equus asinus", "Rangifer tarandus" ], "layer_role": "mapped_direct_comparator", "mapped": true, "feature_count": 0, "evidence_posture": "mapped_comparator_locality_evidence", "provenance_posture": "tracked_species_locality_summaries", "popup_contract": [ "Species", "Support class", "Project accession", "Paper title", "Publication year", "Chronology", "Coordinate confidence", "Nordic relevance", "Interpretation", "Warning" ], "rationale": [ "Comparator species remain distinct from domesticated-core support even when mapped as localities." ] }, { "layer_key": "animal_adna_species_context", "label": "Animal aDNA species context", "species_scope": [], "layer_role": "unmapped_contextual_review", "mapped": false, "feature_count": 0, "evidence_posture": "species_review_context_only", "provenance_posture": "project_and_study_manifests", "popup_contract": [], "rationale": [ "Some animal species still remain project and study review surfaces without mapped locality rows." ] }, { "layer_key": "animal_adna_refused_or_thin", "label": "Animal aDNA refused or thin evidence", "species_scope": [ "Anas platyrhynchos domesticus", "Bos indicus", "Gallus gallus domesticus", "Meleagris gallopavo", "Oryctolagus cuniculus" ], "layer_role": "refusal_guard", "mapped": false, "feature_count": 0, "evidence_posture": "not_publishable_as_atlas_support", "provenance_posture": "governance_and_integrity_review", "popup_contract": [], "rationale": [ "This layer exists only to make weak or blocked species explicit." ] }, { "layer_key": "environmental_context", "label": "Environmental and archaeology context", "species_scope": [], "layer_role": "mapped_context", "mapped": true, "feature_count": 3167, "evidence_posture": "non_adna_context", "provenance_posture": "normalized_context_layers", "popup_contract": [ "Source-specific context rows" ], "rationale": [ "Environmental and archaeology layers help contextualize atlas localities but do not become direct ancient-DNA evidence." ] } ], "species_rows": [ { "species_latin_name": "Homo sapiens", "species_common_name": "human", "support_status": "supported", "product_role": "human_reference", "dataset_bucket": "paper_pinned_core", "contribution_role": "direct", "interaction_posture": "increases_confidence", "mapped_direct_record_count": 447, "curated_project_count": 0, "study_summary_count": 0, "chronology_posture": "mapped_sample_chronology_available", "geography_posture": "mapped_locality_points", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [], "rationale": [ "Homo sapiens atlas evidence is direct because the runtime owns mapped sample and locality metadata.", "The current human layer remains metadata-only and does not imply genotype-aware interpretation." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Anas platyrhynchos domesticus", "species_common_name": "duck", "support_status": "out_of_scope", "product_role": "reject_or_out_of_scope", "dataset_bucket": "reject_or_out_of_scope", "contribution_role": "too_weak", "interaction_posture": "refused", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 0, "study_summary_count": 0, "chronology_posture": "no_curated_nonhuman_chronology", "geography_posture": "no_curated_nonhuman_geography", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [], "rationale": [ "This species remains too weak for atlas contribution because curation or archive proof is still incomplete." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Bos indicus", "species_common_name": "zebu", "support_status": "provisional", "product_role": "domesticated_core", "dataset_bucket": "reject_or_out_of_scope", "contribution_role": "too_weak", "interaction_posture": "refused", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 0, "study_summary_count": 0, "chronology_posture": "no_curated_nonhuman_chronology", "geography_posture": "no_curated_nonhuman_geography", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [ "missing_archive_projects", "mixed_species_rule_unresolved", "missing_archive_paper_pinning_rationale" ], "rationale": [ "This species remains too weak for atlas contribution because curation or archive proof is still incomplete." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Bos taurus", "species_common_name": "cattle", "support_status": "provisional", "product_role": "domesticated_core", "dataset_bucket": "archive_verified_needs_paper_pinning", "contribution_role": "direct", "interaction_posture": "decreases_confidence", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 1, "study_summary_count": 3, "chronology_posture": "project_level_chronology_without_locality_alignment", "geography_posture": "project_level_sites_known_but_not_runtime_mapped", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [ "missing_primary_paper_pins", "missing_archive_paper_pinning_rationale", "ancient_but_not_domesticated_core_projects", "mixed_species_rule_unresolved" ], "rationale": [ "This species now has tracked mapped locality rows and can act as direct atlas evidence with explicit locality caveats.", "Current blocking reasons reduce confidence rather than strengthening the atlas narrative.", "Cattle remains under a mixed-species rule, so wild or progenitor context cannot be flattened into domesticated-core support." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Camelus dromedarius", "species_common_name": "dromedary camel", "support_status": "provisional", "product_role": "domesticated_core", "dataset_bucket": "paper_pinned_core", "contribution_role": "direct", "interaction_posture": "increases_confidence", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 2, "study_summary_count": 1, "chronology_posture": "project_level_chronology_without_locality_alignment", "geography_posture": "project_level_sites_known_but_not_runtime_mapped", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [], "rationale": [ "This species now has tracked mapped locality rows and can act as direct atlas evidence with explicit locality caveats." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Canis lupus familiaris", "species_common_name": "dog", "support_status": "provisional", "product_role": "domesticated_core", "dataset_bucket": "paper_pinned_core", "contribution_role": "direct", "interaction_posture": "increases_confidence", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 3, "study_summary_count": 1, "chronology_posture": "project_level_bp_capable_but_not_locality_bound", "geography_posture": "project_level_sites_known_but_not_runtime_mapped", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [], "rationale": [ "This species now has tracked mapped locality rows and can act as direct atlas evidence with explicit locality caveats." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Capra hircus", "species_common_name": "goat", "support_status": "provisional", "product_role": "domesticated_core", "dataset_bucket": "paper_pinned_core", "contribution_role": "direct", "interaction_posture": "increases_confidence", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 3, "study_summary_count": 3, "chronology_posture": "project_level_chronology_without_locality_alignment", "geography_posture": "project_level_sites_known_but_not_runtime_mapped", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [], "rationale": [ "This species now has tracked mapped locality rows and can act as direct atlas evidence with explicit locality caveats." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Equus asinus", "species_common_name": "donkey", "support_status": "comparator_only", "product_role": "comparator", "dataset_bucket": "comparator_only", "contribution_role": "direct", "interaction_posture": "increases_confidence", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 0, "study_summary_count": 5, "chronology_posture": "project_level_chronology_without_locality_alignment", "geography_posture": "project_level_geography_requires_manual_review", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [], "rationale": [ "This species now has tracked mapped locality rows and can act as direct atlas evidence with explicit locality caveats." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Equus caballus", "species_common_name": "horse", "support_status": "provisional", "product_role": "domesticated_core", "dataset_bucket": "archive_verified_needs_paper_pinning", "contribution_role": "direct", "interaction_posture": "increases_confidence", "mapped_direct_record_count": 2, "curated_project_count": 4, "study_summary_count": 8, "chronology_posture": "mapped_locality_bp_windows_available", "geography_posture": "mapped_locality_points", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [ "missing_primary_paper_pins", "missing_archive_paper_pinning_rationale", "non_ancient_or_unconfirmed_core_projects" ], "rationale": [ "This species now has tracked mapped locality rows and can act as direct atlas evidence with explicit locality caveats." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Felis catus", "species_common_name": "cat", "support_status": "provisional", "product_role": "domesticated_core", "dataset_bucket": "paper_pinned_core", "contribution_role": "direct", "interaction_posture": "increases_confidence", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 2, "study_summary_count": 2, "chronology_posture": "project_level_chronology_without_locality_alignment", "geography_posture": "project_level_sites_known_but_not_runtime_mapped", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [], "rationale": [ "This species now has tracked mapped locality rows and can act as direct atlas evidence with explicit locality caveats." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Gallus gallus domesticus", "species_common_name": "chicken", "support_status": "genbank_only", "product_role": "genbank_only", "dataset_bucket": "reject_or_out_of_scope", "contribution_role": "too_weak", "interaction_posture": "refused", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 0, "study_summary_count": 0, "chronology_posture": "no_curated_nonhuman_chronology", "geography_posture": "no_curated_nonhuman_geography", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [], "rationale": [ "This species remains too weak for atlas contribution because curation or archive proof is still incomplete." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Meleagris gallopavo", "species_common_name": "turkey", "support_status": "genbank_only", "product_role": "genbank_only", "dataset_bucket": "reject_or_out_of_scope", "contribution_role": "too_weak", "interaction_posture": "refused", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 0, "study_summary_count": 0, "chronology_posture": "no_curated_nonhuman_chronology", "geography_posture": "no_curated_nonhuman_geography", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [], "rationale": [ "This species remains too weak for atlas contribution because curation or archive proof is still incomplete." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Oryctolagus cuniculus", "species_common_name": "rabbit", "support_status": "out_of_scope", "product_role": "reject_or_out_of_scope", "dataset_bucket": "reject_or_out_of_scope", "contribution_role": "too_weak", "interaction_posture": "refused", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 0, "study_summary_count": 0, "chronology_posture": "no_curated_nonhuman_chronology", "geography_posture": "no_curated_nonhuman_geography", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [], "rationale": [ "This species remains too weak for atlas contribution because curation or archive proof is still incomplete." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Ovis aries", "species_common_name": "sheep", "support_status": "provisional", "product_role": "domesticated_core", "dataset_bucket": "archive_verified_needs_paper_pinning", "contribution_role": "direct", "interaction_posture": "increases_confidence", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 3, "study_summary_count": 6, "chronology_posture": "project_level_chronology_without_locality_alignment", "geography_posture": "project_level_geography_requires_manual_review", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [ "missing_primary_paper_pins", "missing_archive_paper_pinning_rationale", "non_ancient_or_unconfirmed_core_projects" ], "rationale": [ "This species now has tracked mapped locality rows and can act as direct atlas evidence with explicit locality caveats." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Rangifer tarandus", "species_common_name": "reindeer", "support_status": "comparator_only", "product_role": "comparator", "dataset_bucket": "comparator_only", "contribution_role": "direct", "interaction_posture": "increases_confidence", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 0, "study_summary_count": 4, "chronology_posture": "project_level_chronology_without_locality_alignment", "geography_posture": "project_level_geography_requires_manual_review", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [], "rationale": [ "This species now has tracked mapped locality rows and can act as direct atlas evidence with explicit locality caveats." ] }, { "species_latin_name": "Sus scrofa domesticus", "species_common_name": "pig", "support_status": "provisional", "product_role": "domesticated_core", "dataset_bucket": "archive_verified_needs_paper_pinning", "contribution_role": "direct", "interaction_posture": "increases_confidence", "mapped_direct_record_count": 0, "curated_project_count": 1, "study_summary_count": 4, "chronology_posture": "project_level_chronology_without_locality_alignment", "geography_posture": "project_level_geography_requires_manual_review", "contextual_layer_dependencies": [ "animal-equus-caballus", "fieldwork-documentation", "landclim-sites", "neotoma-pollen", "sead-sites", "sweden-lake-10km-top40", "sweden-lake-20km-top40", "sweden-lake-30km-top40", "sweden-lake-40km-top40", "sweden-lake-50km-top40", "sweden-lake-aggregate-top40", "sweden-lake-consensus-top40", "sweden-lake-fieldwork-shortlist" ], "blocking_reasons": [ "missing_primary_paper_pins", "missing_archive_paper_pinning_rationale" ], "rationale": [ "This species now has tracked mapped locality rows and can act as direct atlas evidence with explicit locality caveats." ] } ], "country_profiles": [ { "country": "Sweden", "mapped_direct_species": [ "Homo sapiens", "Equus caballus" ], "mapped_animal_direct_species": [ "Equus caballus" ], "unmapped_animal_context_species": [], "too_weak_animal_species": [ "Anas platyrhynchos domesticus", "Bos indicus", "Gallus gallus domesticus", "Meleagris gallopavo", "Oryctolagus cuniculus" ], "human_locality_count": 77, "human_sample_count": 416, "mapped_animal_locality_count": 1, "evidence_posture": "human_direct_plus_mapped_animal_direct", "caution_note": "Mapped animal localities can now appear in the atlas, but many remain approximate, regional, comparator-only, or not country-resolved. Do not read this profile as excavation-grade support without the popup caveats." }, { "country": "Norway", "mapped_direct_species": [ "Homo sapiens" ], "mapped_animal_direct_species": [], "unmapped_animal_context_species": [], "too_weak_animal_species": [ "Anas platyrhynchos domesticus", "Bos indicus", "Gallus gallus domesticus", "Meleagris gallopavo", "Oryctolagus cuniculus" ], "human_locality_count": 69, "human_sample_count": 130, "mapped_animal_locality_count": 0, "evidence_posture": "human_only_direct", "caution_note": "Animal aDNA remains atlas-wide unmapped context unless species-owned locality rows exist. This country profile must not be read as country-assigned animal support." }, { "country": "Finland", "mapped_direct_species": [ "Homo sapiens" ], "mapped_animal_direct_species": [], "unmapped_animal_context_species": [], "too_weak_animal_species": [ "Anas platyrhynchos domesticus", "Bos indicus", "Gallus gallus domesticus", "Meleagris gallopavo", "Oryctolagus cuniculus" ], "human_locality_count": 6, "human_sample_count": 32, "mapped_animal_locality_count": 0, "evidence_posture": "human_only_direct", "caution_note": "Animal aDNA remains atlas-wide unmapped context unless species-owned locality rows exist. This country profile must not be read as country-assigned animal support." }, { "country": "Denmark", "mapped_direct_species": [ "Homo sapiens", "Equus caballus" ], "mapped_animal_direct_species": [ "Equus caballus" ], "unmapped_animal_context_species": [], "too_weak_animal_species": [ "Anas platyrhynchos domesticus", "Bos indicus", "Gallus gallus domesticus", "Meleagris gallopavo", "Oryctolagus cuniculus" ], "human_locality_count": 295, "human_sample_count": 653, "mapped_animal_locality_count": 1, "evidence_posture": "human_direct_plus_mapped_animal_direct", "caution_note": "Mapped animal localities can now appear in the atlas, but many remain approximate, regional, comparator-only, or not country-resolved. Do not read this profile as excavation-grade support without the popup caveats." } ], "refusals": [ { "subject": "Anas platyrhynchos domesticus", "reason": "species_support_too_thin_for_atlas_promotion", "detail": "Current curation and archive evidence are not strong enough to count as atlas support." }, { "subject": "Bos indicus", "reason": "species_support_too_thin_for_atlas_promotion", "detail": "Current curation and archive evidence are not strong enough to count as atlas support." }, { "subject": "Bos taurus", "reason": "mapped_animal_chronology_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities exist, but their chronology remains too partial or mixed to support strong time-alignment claims." }, { "subject": "Bos taurus", "reason": "mapped_animal_geography_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities remain approximate, inferred, or regional and must keep their visible caveat warnings." }, { "subject": "Camelus dromedarius", "reason": "mapped_animal_chronology_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities exist, but their chronology remains too partial or mixed to support strong time-alignment claims." }, { "subject": "Camelus dromedarius", "reason": "mapped_animal_geography_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities remain approximate, inferred, or regional and must keep their visible caveat warnings." }, { "subject": "Canis lupus familiaris", "reason": "mapped_animal_chronology_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities exist, but their chronology remains too partial or mixed to support strong time-alignment claims." }, { "subject": "Canis lupus familiaris", "reason": "mapped_animal_geography_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities remain approximate, inferred, or regional and must keep their visible caveat warnings." }, { "subject": "Capra hircus", "reason": "mapped_animal_chronology_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities exist, but their chronology remains too partial or mixed to support strong time-alignment claims." }, { "subject": "Capra hircus", "reason": "mapped_animal_geography_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities remain approximate, inferred, or regional and must keep their visible caveat warnings." }, { "subject": "Equus asinus", "reason": "mapped_animal_chronology_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities exist, but their chronology remains too partial or mixed to support strong time-alignment claims." }, { "subject": "Equus asinus", "reason": "mapped_animal_geography_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities remain approximate, inferred, or regional and must keep their visible caveat warnings." }, { "subject": "Felis catus", "reason": "mapped_animal_chronology_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities exist, but their chronology remains too partial or mixed to support strong time-alignment claims." }, { "subject": "Felis catus", "reason": "mapped_animal_geography_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities remain approximate, inferred, or regional and must keep their visible caveat warnings." }, { "subject": "Gallus gallus domesticus", "reason": "species_support_too_thin_for_atlas_promotion", "detail": "Current curation and archive evidence are not strong enough to count as atlas support." }, { "subject": "Meleagris gallopavo", "reason": "species_support_too_thin_for_atlas_promotion", "detail": "Current curation and archive evidence are not strong enough to count as atlas support." }, { "subject": "Oryctolagus cuniculus", "reason": "species_support_too_thin_for_atlas_promotion", "detail": "Current curation and archive evidence are not strong enough to count as atlas support." }, { "subject": "Ovis aries", "reason": "mapped_animal_chronology_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities exist, but their chronology remains too partial or mixed to support strong time-alignment claims." }, { "subject": "Ovis aries", "reason": "mapped_animal_geography_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities remain approximate, inferred, or regional and must keep their visible caveat warnings." }, { "subject": "Rangifer tarandus", "reason": "mapped_animal_chronology_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities exist, but their chronology remains too partial or mixed to support strong time-alignment claims." }, { "subject": "Rangifer tarandus", "reason": "mapped_animal_geography_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities remain approximate, inferred, or regional and must keep their visible caveat warnings." }, { "subject": "Sus scrofa domesticus", "reason": "mapped_animal_chronology_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities exist, but their chronology remains too partial or mixed to support strong time-alignment claims." }, { "subject": "Sus scrofa domesticus", "reason": "mapped_animal_geography_requires_caution", "detail": "Mapped animal localities remain approximate, inferred, or regional and must keep their visible caveat warnings." } ], "north_star_boundary": "Mapped Homo sapiens localities are direct atlas evidence. Non-human ancient-DNA support becomes direct atlas evidence only where tracked species-owned locality rows exist. Approximate coordinates, regional leads, comparator species, and mixed-species claims still require explicit caution." }